Editor's Note
This is the second article in a two-part series. Part one focused on ‘When Institutions Define What Counts as Mission: Recovering Theological Discernment in an Age of Visibility’.
For over a decade, I have self-funded what I understand as integral mission, working through food, art and clay. The categories discussed here decide whether work like mine gets funded or merely admired — and admiration, unlike funding, is free.
That gives me a stake in the argument. It does not give me an exemption from it.
The church confesses that God exceeds human understanding, then asks God’s work to fit on a form. God may exceed our understanding, apparently, provided God does not exceed our formats.
So the question is not what the church has failed to see. Failures of sight are forgivable; everyone has them. The question is what happens when testimony exposes a failure of judgement — whether the institution revises the judgement, or asks the witness to revise the testimony.
Classification is not the villain. Budgets require decisions, and decisions require categories. But classifications do more than sort: they determine what becomes visible, comparable and fundable.¹ A form can settle a theological question before anyone notices one was asked.

1. A Definition with a Budget Behind It
For half a century the evangelical movement has repeatedly affirmed the inseparability of evangelism and social responsibility: from the Lausanne Covenant in 1974 and the Grand Rapids consultation in 1982, through the Micah Declaration in 2001 and the Cape Town Commitment in 2010, to the Seoul Statement in 2024.²
Fifty years of affirmation makes the question of implementation unavoidable. Where recognition and funding remain unchanged, renewal risks becoming commemoration.
John Meyer and Brian Rowan named the mechanism: decoupling, the loose fit between an organisation’s formal commitments and its actual operations.³ A church can affirm integral mission with complete sincerity and change nothing about how mission is recognised or resourced. The theology moves; the budget stays.
Integral mission is warmly endorsed in classrooms, while fields and sending remain the routes through which mission is actually funded and staffed.
In the Hong Kong structures I know, integral mission is warmly endorsed in classrooms, while fields and sending remain the routes through which mission is actually funded and staffed.
Here the obvious suspect is innocent. Cross-cultural missionaries are not this system’s gatekeepers; they are its most audited subjects. They raise their own support, file newsletters, report decisions, submit to evaluation, and discover on furlough that the one thing the home church wants is a moving story. Let a missionary say something inconvenient — about short-term trips that leave damage behind, about the quiet asymmetries of money — and they too will be thanked, applauded, and returned to the platform to tell the story again.
The missionary and the unclassifiable practitioner are not competitors for a shrinking pot. They are two people managed by the same metrics.
The issue is not whether overseas mission matters. It is whether every other form must imitate its administrative shape to become legible.
Once a definition has a budget behind it, it stops being an idea. It decides which practices can employ staff, sustain relationships, and produce the evidence institutions recognise. Supported work generates recognisable evidence; that evidence returns at the next funding round as proof the original decision was sound. Unsupported work rarely survives long enough to produce anything comparable — and its lack of outcomes becomes a further reason not to support it.
The institution thus manufactures the disparity it later evaluates, and calls the result a track record.
Which is why invitations to grassroots innovation deserve a second look. Let believers experiment. Let new forms emerge. Charming — but where there is no category, there is no funding line. The invitation leaves the risk with the practitioner and the authority to recognise success with the institution. Personal enthusiasm fills the gap, followed by personal savings, unpaid labour, and eventually self-exploitation in the costume of a calling.
If the work succeeds, it is welcomed into a narrative of renewal. If it collapses, the failure is attributed to the practitioner’s capacity or spiritual depth. The arrangement that withheld support is never the subject of the post-mortem.
An institution need not suppress innovation to control it. It needs only to let others carry the risk and reserve the right to claim the result.
What can be counted must not decide what counts.
Evaluation preserves the same split. A form will happily count attendance, decisions and training hours while having no column for a repaired relationship, an altered perception, or a cultural shift that takes fifteen years to surface. Counting is not the enemy of discernment. But what can be counted must not decide what counts.
No conspiracy is required. It is enough that everyone keeps recognising everyone else.

2. When the Witness Starts Asking Questions
John 9 turns a healing into a jurisdictional dispute over who may interpret what has happened.
“I do not know whether he is a sinner. One thing I do know, that though I was blind, now I see.” (9:25)
He concedes the limits of his knowledge without letting those limits erase it. He cannot yet give a full account of Jesus. But another man’s certainty cannot un-open his eyes.
His interrogators begin from the other end:
“We know that this man is a sinner.” (9:24)
The verdict precedes the testimony. The threat of expulsion has already been established (9:22). Questions continue; the hearing does not.
This is not a morality play. The Pharisees are divided among themselves (9:16) and freely admit they do not know where this man comes from (9:29). The line does not fall between those who know and those who don’t, but between two ways of holding what one knows.
We know is not inherently arrogant. Nicodemus says oidamen (Greek οἴδαμεν: we know) in 3:2; the healed man says it in 9:31. In 9:24 and 9:29 the explicit pronoun hémeis (Greek ἡμεῖς: we, us, ourselves) foregrounds the speaking group.⁴ The pronoun does not mark pride. It marks who is issuing the claim — and whether that issuer can be corrected.
The man does not plead experience to escape argument. He reasons from premises his interrogators accept, and turns their own theology against their verdict: if this man were not from God, he could do nothing (9:30–33).
They do not answer the argument. They disqualify the arguer:
“You were born entirely in sins, and are you trying to teach us?” (9:34)
Then they drive him out.
Note the move: not refutation but revocation. He was summoned as a source of data. He was never meant to become a source of instruction.⁵
A witness may be permitted to supply facts and forbidden to question the framework that interprets them.
The hearing stays open exactly until the witness starts asking questions.

3. Two Issuers, One Exchange Rate
John 5:44 diagnoses the problem before sociology is needed:
“How can you believe when you accept glory from one another and do not seek the glory that comes from the one who alone is God?”
The Greek keeps them apart: doxan para allēlōn, glory from one another, and tēn doxan tēn para monou Theou, the glory from the only God. John 12:43 repeats the contrast.⁶
Two issuers. The texts never authorise a conversion between their currencies.
That is precisely what institutions invent: an exchange rate. Our endorsement becomes evidence of divine approval; what we have not endorsed remains spiritually unproven. Nobody decrees this. It is simply what our arrangements assume the moment institutional recognition becomes the practical precondition for recognising God’s work.
Bourdieu explains the human side. Symbolic capital is capital perceived and recognised as legitimate: people are not merely heard, they are heard as credible.⁷ Bourdieu does not supply the theological distinction — John does. Sociology only explains why surrendering one currency is so expensive.
A judgement is rarely just an opinion. It supports a reputation, a role, a past allocation of funds, a network of mutual endorsement. To revise it is to devalue one’s own holdings.
John 9 prices this precisely. “Give glory to God,” the interrogators say (9:24) — in that idiom, a solemn demand to tell the truth, as Joshua demanded of Achan.⁸ And immediately: we know that this man is a sinner.
Tell the truth. Just don’t disturb the finding.
His parents understand the market. They confirm the identity and the blindness, then refer all interpretive questions to their son; the narrator names their motive as fear (9:20–23). Fear does not delete their knowledge. It determines how much of it they will stand behind.
The church has its own costs of acknowledgement. To recognise work it long declined to fund is to concede that its categories were inadequate. To take a marginal practitioner seriously is to unsettle those accustomed to deciding who is worth hearing.
So testimony can be welcomed on condition that it remains inert. It may become a sharing session, an article, a photograph, a credential of openness. It may not become a reason to move money or redistribute interpretive authority.
The institution banks the credit for listening and avoids the inconvenience of having listened.
Whose glory, then, decides what we are willing to acknowledge?

4. Difference We Can Display, Otherness We Cannot Control
The man was a beggar (9:8). That does not mean he had nothing to lose. The poor also need belonging, kinship, material help; expulsion does not hurt less because one began with little prestige.
The poor also need belonging, kinship, material help; expulsion does not hurt less because one began with little prestige.
Nor does marginality confer correctness. What distinguishes him is not his status but his willingness to let the event revise his theology: “the man called Jesus” (9:11), then “a prophet” (9:17), then one who must be from God (9:33). He did not start with a finished doctrine. He started with a fact he refused to surrender.
After his expulsion, Jesus seeks him out and discloses himself; in the longer reading, the man believes and worships (9:35–38).⁹ The encounter continues past the point where the tribunal declared the matter closed.
Byung-Chul Han describes a society that consumes difference while dissolving the otherness that resists assimilation into the Same.¹⁰ Translated into church life: do we welcome people insofar as they enrich our story, or also when they interrupt it?
A church can absorb difference while refusing otherness with great warmth. It will welcome unfamiliar dishes, affecting testimonies, photographs of the people it serves. It will be markedly less enthusiastic when those same people question its priorities, its competence, or its accounts.
If the marginalised may demonstrate our compassion but not expose our errors, their inclusion is simply our curation.
Jesus’ closing line is the sharpest in the chapter: “but now that you say, ‘We see,’ your sin remains” (9:41). The verb is menei — the same verb that elsewhere in John carries abiding in Christ and in his love (15:4–10).¹¹ Different contexts, unkind echo: persistence is not a virtue in itself. Everything depends on what one persists in.
Jesus does not condemn knowledge. He confronts the claim to sight when it has become immune to correction.
The church does not need a wider range of people to exhibit. It needs their presence to have consequences.

5. Four Requests
Rhetorical questions are cheap, and I have asked several. So, four requests at the level of category, not project:
- A support route that does not presuppose sending. Mission structures are built around departure: a field, a term, a return. Work that is resident, long-term and local should not have to disguise itself as deployment to be legible.
- Plural, practitioner-informed review. Evaluation proportionate to what the work actually undertakes, drawing on relevant practitioners and affected communities rather than a single administrative form. A new guild of recognised practitioners certifying each other would merely relocate the problem. Rigour is not uniformity; a standardised form is not a higher standard, only a shorter one.
- Small, multi-year grants that tolerate non-comparable outcomes. Enough to let a practice survive into visibility. Short cycles do not select for faithfulness; they select for work that photographs well early.
- A route by which a witness can contest the category, not merely appeal the decision. This is the John 9 test, and the only one that matters. Appealing a decision accepts the classification and disputes its application. Contesting the category asks whether the classification should govern at all. If testimony can alter the metric, the church is listening. If testimony can only compete within it, the church is collecting.
None of this can be reduced to a demand for more money. Some of it costs money; all of it costs something. What it requires first is that the authority to classify and allocate be open to review by those it classifies.
Conclusion: What Testimony Is Allowed to Change
For more than a decade after my theological studies, I have self-funded mission through food, art and clay. These are different media for encountering people and the world — not illustrations of a message already settled.
Where speech is difficult, materials carry knowledge that words alone cannot. People need not master our vocabulary before we recognise them.
In ministry with sex workers, participants introduced themselves through a favourite dish from home, not the life story a ministry might expect. They began with something they knew how to make. They were people, not cases. Whatever help they needed, need was not their identity.
Teaching students with special educational needs to work in sgraffito — scratching patterns through coloured underglaze — reminded me that everyone needs room to discover what a first impression conceals. Others must give us that room; sometimes we must give it to ourselves. What has not yet emerged is not necessarily absent.
Nobody has to reveal a hidden talent to deserve recognition. The question is whether our categories leave room for a person we have not yet learned to see.
Food and clay carry alternative knowledge. Cooking reveals judgement, habit and formation through the handling of heat, ingredients and guests. Clay records pressure, hesitation and attention. Neither reveals a soul. Both tell us more than words alone.
I introduce friction deliberately: a glitch in prediction, where experience interrupts expectation and a settled judgement becomes open to revision. I hope that opening becomes soil for faith. The movement is from perception to formation to participation: seeing differently, being reshaped, participating more attentively in the Missio Dei.
This has grown into work on food theology and theological aesthetics, and I am grateful to the seminaries that have made room for it.¹² But practice came before theory. I learned through cooking, making, waiting and meeting. The materials have corrected me. Institutions must be capable of the same.
A meal can begin with a recipe. It cannot be made by one. Food and clay require attention, adjustment and response. Knowing what should happen is not the same as noticing what is happening.
Mission this way offers no guarantee of what an encounter will change. It must still answer for its treatment of people, its costs, its failures and what it makes possible. Accountability is necessary. Turning change still awaiting discernment into promised deliverables is not.
What keeps me at it is the hope that the world might see God.
My account, methods and judgment need correction. I do not ask my testimony to win the argument. I ask that testimony from outside the categories be allowed to change the argument — not merely enter it.
If integral mission has been affirmed since 1974, why must some of its forms still survive on private savings? The church cannot praise the sacrifice indefinitely while refusing to examine what makes it necessary.
Ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda secundum verbum Dei — the church reformed, always to be reformed according to the Word of God.¹³ That correction must reach beyond doctrine to government, budgets and the machinery that recognises mission.
Not another story for the collection. A test of what stories can change. Can testimony overturn a category? Can transformation force a revision of the metrics? Can someone we called marginal give us reason to reconsider — and have any purchase on the decision?
The problem is not that the church cannot know everything. It is that its arrangements can make admitting ignorance more costly than preserving error.
The problem is that the Church’s arrangements can make admitting ignorance more costly than preserving error.
God’s freedom must be allowed to cost us something: a settled judgement, a budget line, our peers’ approval, a share of the authority to interpret.
If none of those may be touched, “God exceeds our understanding” is a remarkably safe thing to say.
We still know. Everyone else must explain themselves.
Endnotes
- Geoffrey C. Bowker and Susan Leigh Star, Sorting Things Out: Classification and Its Consequences (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1999), introduction, on how classifications embed values and carry material consequences.
- These are not five restatements of one fixed concept, and the essay’s claim is about the recurrence of re-affirmation, not identity of content. The Lausanne Covenant (1974), §5, addresses “Christian Social Responsibility.” Evangelism and Social Responsibility: An Evangelical Commitment, Lausanne Occasional Paper 21, from the Consultation on the Relationship between Evangelism and Social Responsibility, Grand Rapids, 19–25 June 1982, treats the relation between the two directly. The Micah Declaration on Integral Mission (2001) is the landmark statement of integral mission as a named concept. The Cape Town Commitment (2010), I.10B, quotes and extends that definition. The Seoul Statement (Lausanne Theology Working Group, 22 September 2024), §V, states that Lausanne’s “dual emphases have often been held together within the concept of ‘integral mission,’ but integral mission has not always fully integrated the command of our Lord to be disciples and his commission to make disciples” — a concern with holiness and discipleship, not with funding mechanisms.
- John W. Meyer and Brian Rowan, “Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony,” American Journal of Sociology 83, no. 2 (1977): 340–363. The application to theological commitments and mission funding is mine. My description of Hong Kong structures reflects my own experience over more than a decade and is offered as testimony inviting corroboration, not as survey data.
- John 3:2; 9:24, 29, 31 in the Greek text. οἴδαμεν already carries the first-person plural; the explicit ἡμεῖς foregrounds the speaking group. Biblical quotations follow the NRSVue except where noted.
- On 9:22 and 9:34, J. Louis Martyn’s History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel (1968; 3rd ed., Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2003) proposed that the ἀποσυνάγωγος references reflect a formal expulsion in the evangelist’s own period. The hypothesis remains influential but contested: see Edward W. Klink III, “Expulsion from the Synagogue? Rethinking a Johannine Anachronism,” Tyndale Bulletin 59, no. 1 (2008): 99–118. I therefore do not treat ἐξέβαλον αὐτὸν ἔξω (9:34) as evidence of a formal synagogue ban; “drive out” renders the narrative action only. Adele Reinhartz, Befriending the Beloved Disciple: A Jewish Reading of the Gospel of John (New York: Continuum, 2001), has pressed the ethical question of how Johannine conflict narratives have been used against Jews. Accordingly, “the authorities” and “the interrogators” denote the narrative’s religious leadership and the institutional dynamic the text exposes; nothing here licenses a judgement about Judaism or Jewish people, and the critique is addressed to the Christian institutions I belong to.
- John 5:44; 12:43. “Two issuers” and “one exchange rate” are my own formulations — a deliberate financial metaphor, not a theological category. God’s glory and the glory we trade among ourselves are not two comparable capitals, which is the point: the metaphor names the institutional attempt to make them convertible.
- Pierre Bourdieu, “The Forms of Capital,” in Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, ed. John G. Richardson (New York: Greenwood, 1986), 241–258, esp. n. 3: symbolic capital is capital perceived and recognised as legitimate.
- John 9:24 with Joshua 7:19; see D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Leicester: IVP; Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1991), on 9:24, for the phrase as a solemn adjuration to tell the truth.
- See the NET Bible textual note at John 9:39: some significant early witnesses omit the words corresponding to 9:38–39a. The saying “For judgment I have come” is not part of that omission; Jesus seeking out the expelled man is narrated at 9:35–37.
- Byung-Chul Han, The Expulsion of the Other: Society, Perception and Communication Today, trans. Wieland Hoban (Cambridge: Polity, 2018), esp. “The Terror of the Same.” Han’s concern is the dissolution of otherness within a society of the Same, not simply the exclusion of dissenters; the ecclesial application is mine.
- John 9:41: ἡ ἁμαρτία ὑμῶν μένει, “your sin remains.” Forms of μένω recur at John 15:4–10 for abiding in Christ and in his love. The juxtaposition is a literary observation, not a claim of shared theological referent.
- For Lausanne’s own engagement with the arts, see Redeeming the Arts: The Restoration of the Arts to God’s Creational Intention, Lausanne Occasional Paper 46, Issue Group 17, Forum for World Evangelization, Pattaya, 29 September – 5 October 2004. The claim that artistic and material practice still lacks a standard funding route two decades later does not follow from that document; it is my own observation of the structures I work in, and is offered as a claim open to correction.
- Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Book of Order, F-2.02: the Church is “open to the reform of its standards of doctrine as well as of governance,” affirming “Ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda secundum verbum Dei,” that is, “The church reformed, always to be reformed according to the Word of God” in the power of the Spirit.
